Drugs for Asthma/COPD: A Medical Primer

Lawrence Martin, M.D., FACP, FCCP

Return to Asthma Home Page

COMMENTS ON CLASSIFICATION. There are so many types of drugs for asthma and COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease), plus different ways of taking them, that it can be confusing to everyone - doctors, nurses, patients, families. To clarify the situation I am presenting two different classifications, one based on mechanism of action and the other on how the drug is taken (swallowed, inhaled, etc). If you wish to skip the introduction, click on one of the choices below.

Asthma/COPD Drugs: classified by Mechanism of Action

Asthma/COPD Drugs: classified by How You Take Them


INTRODUCTION

Our lungs contain many branching airways that deliver fresh air to the blood, as shown below.


Lungs & Airways


Alveoli

Lungs and airways, from BREATHE EASY, by Lawrence Martin, MD. Top figure shows both lungs and the large branching airways. Airways divide into the bronchioles, which are the smallest airways before reaching the alveoli, where oxygen and carbon dioxide are exchanged between blood and the atmosphere. Inhaled asthma drugs work on the larger airways shown in the top figure, and not on the alveli.


The phrase "drugs for asthma and COPD" means drugs that help open up the airways when they become narrowed due to disease. COPD, or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, includes "chronic bronchitis" and "emphysema," conditions which often co-exist in the same patient. Patients with COPD may also have asthma or an "asthma component." Also, patients originally diagnosed "with asthma" may have features of COPD. As a result of this overlap, the same drugs are commonly used in patients with any of the following diagnoses:

-- Asthma
-- COPD
-- Chronic bronchitis
-- Emphysema
-- Asthmatic bronchitis

NOTE: When aproving drugs for asthma or COPD, the FDA considers them as separate conditions, and requires drug companies to study the drug in "pure" populations of patients. Generally, "asthmatics" are younger, have never smoked and their lung function returns to normal or near normal with maximum treatment. Generally, "COPD patients" are older, have a long smoking history, and their lung function does not return to normal or near normal with maximum treatment.

Because different populations are studied for each drug, you will find some drugs FDA-approved for asthma only, some for COPD only, and in some cases (when enough studies have been done) approved for both conditions. In actual practice, because there is much overlap of COPD with asthma, a patient "with asthma" may receive a drug approved "for COPD" and vice versa. Since these drugs (except for Primatene Mist) are all by prescription, the decision of which drug to use when will be up to the physician.

Other drugs may be used in patients who suffer from asthma and COPD, such as antibiotics for infection, but they are not used to directly "open up" the airways.

When it comes to drugs for "opening up" the airways, all available medications can be classified by one of two basic mechanisms of action: bronchodilater and anti-inflammatory.

Bronchodilators "dilate" or open up the bronchi, which are the larger airways delivering air inside the lungs (see top figure). They do this by acting on smooth muscle in the walls of the bronchi. Anti-inflammatory drugs, by contrast, act to decrease the inflammation inside the airways; in this case "inflammation" means fluid and cellular debri that tends to clog up the airways of people with asthma and COPD.

Based on specific biochemical mechanism of action, there are 3 types of bronchodilators and 3 types of anti-inflammatory drugs used in asthma and COPD, This should be a simple classification, but complexity arises because within each of these 6 categories, the drugs can be given by different routes (e.g., orally with a pill; inhalation with a spray or dry powder; by injection into the tissues or directly into the vein) and similar drugs can be used for different purposes.

For example, while most bronchodilators are given by inhalation, and are used mainly for immediate relief of symptoms, several newer ones (such as Serevent, Foradil and Spiriva) are "long acting", and used mainly to prevent symptoms, not to provide immediate relief.

The situation with anti-inflammatory drugs is even more complicated. Steroids (also known as corticosteroids) are powerful anti-asthma drugs that work by reducing airway inflammation. However, they only provide relief of symptoms when taken in pill form or when injected into the muscle or directly into the vein. When steroids are inhaled, they don't provide sufficient dose to relieve symptoms; instead, the low dose of inhaled steroids is used mainly to prevent a worsening of symptoms, or to improve mild symptoms over the long term (days).

Another class of anti-inflammatory drugs, called mediator-release inhibitors (brand names Cromolyn and Tilade), also doesn't provide quick relief of symptoms; the two drugs in this group are used mainly as preventive medication, i.e., to prevent symptoms from worsening or from occurring in the first place.

The newest of the three classes of anti-inflammatory drugs are the anti-leukotrienes (brands are Accolate, Singulair, Zyflo). They also doesn't provide any quick relief, but may help to control asthma symptoms over the long term.

How is the patient to sort all this out?

It's not easy, particularly since there is far from universal agreement among physicians about how to best use asthma/COPD drugs. A patient with asthma symptoms could go to three different physicians and end up with three different regimens, each with a different level of effectiveness.

A rule of thumb is that the sicker the asthmatic or COPD patient, the more likely he or she will need (and benefit by) steroids, either in pill form or systemically (injected into the muscle or vein). Steroids will usually be prescribed along with a quick-acting bronchodilator, given by inhalation.

The other two classes of anti-inflammatory drugs (mediator-release inhibitors and anti-leukotrienes), as well as all inhaled steroids, should not be relied on to provide quick relief to a suffering asthmatic.

Of the drugs listed below, only Primatene Mist (a short acting, inhaled bronchdilator) is sold over the counter in the U.S. All others are by prescription only. Primatene is a very short acting drug, and while it can provide some immediate relief, it does not provide any anti-inflammatory activity. Thus it is imperative that any suffering asthmatic or COPD patient get under the care of a physician who is knowledgeable about the available medications and how to manage flareups of asthma and COPD.

One other point needs to be made about COPD, or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. COPD is found mainly in long term smokers. The term COPD comprises two similar conditions, chronic bronchitis and emphysema. It is usually not important to distinguish whether a person has mainly chronic bronchitis or emphysema; physicians routinely use "COPD" to cover either one or both conditions.

What is important is to recognize that symptoms of a flare up of COPD (e.g., cough, shortness of breath, wheezing, chest congestion) can be identical to symptoms from asthma, so the same drugs listed below are used in both conditions: asthma (which itself is not due to smoking) and COPD (usually due to smoking). There is very little, if any, difference in the use of these drugs in treating symptomatic COPD and asthma patients.



Drugs for Asthma and COPD

Classified by Mechanism of Action

NOTES: Generic names are listed, with brand names in brackets. This is not an exhaustive list, but it does contain most of the drugs used in the U.S. for asthma and COPD. Combination drugs are listed twice, under each of the two ingredients. Drugs delivered via hand-held inhaler (designated HH) are all problematic because of non-standard devices and difficulty many patients have in using them correctly. Furthermore, training in how to use hand-helds is erratic. FOR MORE INFORMATION ON DRUGS DELIVERED VIA HAND-HELD INHALER, PLEASE SEE 10 COMMON ERRORS IN TREATING ASTHMA (Errors 1 & 2 in this web site) .


I. Bronchodilator Drugs


1. Beta-adrenergics - stimulate the beta adrenergic nervous system, which helps relax the airway muscles and dilate the airways

a. Quick-acting inhaled medication. Medication may be inhaled from a hand-held inhaler (HH) or via a nebulizer (N) that is electric- or battery-powered. Medication effect usually occurs within 10 minutes of inhalation.

  • epinephrine [Primatene Mist]: HH; only over-the-counter inhaler
  • metaproterenol [Alupent]: HH or N
  • albuterol [Proventil HFA, ProAir HFA, Ventolin HFA]: HH or N
    NOTE: On December 31, 2008 albuterol containing CFC propellant (chlorofluorocarbon) ceased to be sold in the U.S. It has been replaced by inhalers containing HFA (hydrofluoroalkane). Click here for FDA information on replacement of all CFC inhalers with HFA inhalers.
  • Combination albuterol + ipratropium bromide [DuoNeb]: N
  • albuterol + ipratropium bromide combination [Combivent]: HH
  • levalbuterol [Xopenex]: HH or N
  • pirbuterol [Maxair]: HH

b. Long-acting inhaled medication. Inhaled from a hand-held (HH) inhaler or via an electric- or battery-powered nebulizer (N). Onset of action for this group is slower and longer lasting than short-acting inhalers. Drugs in this group are used to prevent acute symptoms and not for immediate relief. Dose is given every 12 hours. In the combination drugs formoterol is the beta adrenergic drug and budesonide is a steroid.

c. Subcutaneous injection. Works quickly.
  • epinephrine

d. Oral (pill or tablet).
  • albuterol [Vospire]
  • metoprolol [generic]
  • terbutaline [Brethine]

----> BETA-ADRENERGIC AGENTS ARE NOT USED INTRAVENOUSLY IN ADULTS


2. Methyl xanthines

a. Oral (pill or tablet)
  • caffeine
  • theophylline [Theo-24, Theolair]
  • oxtriphylline [Choledyl]

b. Intravenous (aminophylline)

-->THEOPHYLLINE AND OTHER TYPES OF METHYL XANTHINES ARE NOT USED BY INHALATION


a. Inhaled anti-cholinergic - short-acting. Acts within @10 minutes

  • ipratropium bromide [Atrovent]

b. Inhaled anti-cholinergic - long-acting. Lasts 24 hours, used once a day

  • tiotropium [Spiriva]

----> ANTI-CHOLINERGICS NOT AVAILABLE IN ORAL OR PILL FORM



II. Anti-inflammatory Drugs


1. Corticosteroids

----> Inhaled; not used for quick relief.

----> Oral (prednisone, prednisolone, methylprednisolone [Medrol, Medrol DosePak], dexamethasone)

----> Intramuscular (methylprednisolone [Depo-Medrol])

----> Intravenous (hydrocortisone [SoluCortef], methylprednisolone [SoluMedrol], dexamethasone)


2. Mediator-release inhibitors

----> Inhaled only (cromolyn sodium [Intal], nedocromil sodium [Tilade])

NOTE: Both drugs are used only for prophylaxis of asthma, not for treatment of the acute attack or for the symptomatic patient.

----> THESE TWO DRUGS DRUGS ARE NOT AVAILABLE IN ORAL FORM


3. Anti-leukotriene drugs

----> Oral.

  • Accolate(released 1996), generic name zafirlukast
  • Zyflo (released 1997), generic name zileuton
  • Singulair (released 1998), generic name montelukast

----> ANTI-LEUKOTRIENE DRUGS ARE NOT USED BY INHALATION



Drugs for Asthma and COPD

Classified by How You Take Them

NOTES: Generic names are listed, with brand names in brackets. This is not an exhaustive list, but it does contain most of the drugs used in the U.S. Atrovent is not approved for asthma, but only for COPD. The anti-leukotrienes are only approved for asthma, and not COPD. Some of these drugs are combined together, such as Advair and Symbicort; the combinations are indicated in each section.



I. By Inhalation

There are two major ways of inhaling Asthma/COPD drugs:1) via a hand held device that requires no external power source; 2) via a nebulizer; this requires either an electric outlet or battery for operation. For the nebulizer you must place liquid medication into the chamber, where it is 'nebulized' (made into fine particles) for inhalation.

1. Via a hand-held device.

THERE ARE MANY TYPES OF HAND-HELD DEVICES AND THEY ALL HAVE PROBLEMS IS USAGE. THERE IS NO STANDARD FOR THESE DEVICES. TRAINING IN HOW TO USE THEM IS ERRATIC AND MANY PATIENTS USE THEM INCORRECTLY. FOR MORE INFORMATION ON USE OF HAND-HELD INHALERS, PLEASE SEE 10 COMMON ERRORS IN TREATING ASTHMA (Errors 1 & 2 in this web site) .

a. Short acting bronchodilators - for quick relief. All act within @10 minutes; are called 'rescue inhalers'.
  • epinephrine [Primatene Mist]
  • isoproterenol [Isuprel]
  • isoetharine [Bronkosol]
  • metaproterenol [Alupent, Metaprel]
  • albuterol [Proventil HFA, ProAir HFA, Ventolin HFA]
    NOTE: On December 31, 2008 albuterol containing CFC propellant (chlorofluorocarbon) ceased to be sold in the U.S. It has been replaced by inhalers containing HFA (hydrofluoroalkane). Click here for FDA information on replacement of all CFC inhalers with HFA inhalers.
  • isomeric albuterol [Xopenex[
  • terbutaline [Bricanyl, Brethine]
  • pirbuterol [Maxair]
  • atropine [Atrovent]

b. Long acting medication. 'Maintenance medication' that is inhaled once or twice a day; not for quick relief, but to prevent symptoms.

Primarily bronchodilators

  • tiotropium [Spiriva]
  • formoterol [Foradil]

Primarily anti-inflammatory

  • beclomethasone [Vanceril, Beclovent]
  • triamcinolone [Azmacort]
  • flunisolide [Aerobid]
  • fluticasone [Flovent]
  • budesonide [Pulmicort]
  • dexamethasone

Combination bronchodilator and anti-inflammatory

2. Via a nebulizer (either electric- or battery-powered)

a. Short-acting bronchodilators - for quick relief. All act within @10 minutes.

a. Long acting medication. Inhaled via nebulizer twice a day. Not for quick relief, but to prevent symptoms.


II. By Swallowing (pill, tablet or capsule)

Primarily bronchodilators

  • albuterol
  • theophylline
  • choledyl

Primarily anti-inflammatory - steroids

  • prednisone [generic]
  • methylprednisolone [Medrol]
Primarily anti-inflammatory - anti-leukotrienes
  • zafirlukast [Accolate]
  • zileuton [Zyflo]
  • montelukast [Singulair]

III. By Injection

Medications by injection are given to the patient and are not self-injected (as is insulin, for example). Drugs that physicians order for injection include:

  • epinephrine - subcutaenous
  • terbutaline - subcutaneous
  • steroids - intramuscular or intravenous
  • aminophylline - intravenous



Return to top of page / Return to Asthma Home Page / Return to Index of Dr. Martin's web sites